Call Us Today 850-438-9647


To robocall or not to robocall

Posted by Charles S. Liberis | Jun 30, 2017 | 0 Comments


The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) allows consumers to sue companies who call via an automatic dialing system without prior consent. Many lawsuits against creditors and collection agencies revolve around the specific issue of consent when it comes to “robocalls.”

A recent case involved Alberto Reyes, the plaintiff, who had leased a car through Ford Motor Co.'s Lincoln Automotive Financial Services. The application signed by Reyes had a provision that allowed Lincoln to make contact calls as part of the overall agreement. When Reyes stopped making payments, Lincoln responded with calls to collect the past due debt.

Upon hearing from Lincoln, Reyes requested that they stop calling him. Lincoln refused and the pursuit of the amount he owed continued via automated phone calls.

Reyes responded with a lawsuit against Lincoln over allegations that they violated the TCPA. The trial court ruled that Reyes' consent was part of a contract to lease a car from Lincoln. As part of that agreement, it simply could not be revoked.

Reyes appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.

The appellate court agreed with the lower court and ruled that Reyes agreed to a valid contract containing the disputed clause. He simply cannot go back on that agreement because the language that permits phone calls could not have been created without it.

The court did admit that they are sensitive to the argument of businesses inserting consent clauses that may undermine the TCPA. However, that concern is based more on public policy considerations than legal ones. Resolving the problems that arise over robocall permission as part of contracts should come from the legislature.

Posted on Business Litigation

About the Author

Charles S. Liberis

Charles S. Liberis is a native of Pensacola and a graduate of Stetson University College of Law. Mr. Liberis started his career as legislative aide to Congressman Robert L. F. Sikes of Florida. Upon returning to Florida he started the Liberis Law Firm. The Firm is a boutique law firm focusi...


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

How Can We Help You?

Our attorneys are ready to handle all your asset protection, business, estate planning, real estate, and tax resolution needs. Arrange a consultation with us by calling 850-438-9647 or contact us online.